
£10bn Forgone: Miliband Called Rosebank 'Vandalism' While Labour Approved Jackdaw
November 17, 2026 · Frisian News
Photo: Wikimedia Commons
Ed Miliband branded Rosebank, the North Sea's largest untapped field with up to 500 million barrels, 'climate vandalism,' while his Labour government approved the Jackdaw gas field and a certificate scheme producing 60 million barrels, forgoing an estimated £10 billion in tax revenue through 2030.
Between 300 million and 500 million barrels of oil lie beneath the North Sea, 60 miles west of Shetland. Ed Miliband, when he was Energy Secretary, called developing that resource "climate vandalism." His Labour government then approved the Jackdaw gas field, which the Institute for Government records as capable of delivering 6.5 percent of Britain's predicted gas production at peak, while introducing a certificate scheme the government says could produce a further 60 million barrels.
Rosebank, the North Sea's largest undeveloped site, is owned by Ithaca Energy and Adura. By March 2026 the two companies had invested more than £3 billion in the project. The production vessel Petrojarl Rosebank was already rounding Africa, due in Scottish waters the following month, with first production targeted for 2026-27. The only thing missing was ministerial consent.
The government's stated position has been that more North Sea drilling would not improve UK energy security or affect prices. The legal challenges to Rosebank centred on scope 3 emissions, the carbon produced when oil is eventually burned, which the government was required to assess before granting fresh consent. Labour also committed in its 2024 manifesto to issue no new licences, though it pledged to honour existing ones. Both Jackdaw and Rosebank carry licences granted by the previous Conservative government.
That logic does not hold consistently. In November 2025 the government announced Transitional Energy Certificates to allow limited production on or near existing fields. BBC reporting on the resulting Energy Independence Bill notes the scheme could produce about 60 million barrels. On 21 October 2026, Miatta Fahnbulleh, Miliband's successor under Prime Minister Andy Burnham, gave Jackdaw formal consent. The Institute for Government records Jackdaw at peak would account for 6.5 percent of the UK's predicted gas production, heating more than 1.4 million homes.
Rosebank still awaits a decision. So does Cambo, which the Telegraph describes as "almost as large as Rosebank," and the mainly-gas Tornado field. All carry existing licences. All need fresh development consent. Yaniv Friedman, Ithaca's executive chairman, said in March 2026 that Cambo and Tornado could reach a final investment decision within 12 months.
Government modelling, cited by the Telegraph and Share Talk, puts the cost of blocking North Sea expansion at £10 billion in forgone tax revenue between now and 2030. The fiscal pressure on what remains of the industry is already severe. Ithaca made pre-tax profits of $840 million but posted a post-tax loss of $84 million last year. Iain Lewis, Ithaca's chief financial officer, said the North Sea windfall levy had driven the company's effective tax rate to 110 percent.
David Whitehouse, chief executive of industry body Offshore Energies UK, told the BBC that Britain now imports more than 40 percent of the energy it needs. Aberdeen and Grampian Chamber of Commerce chief executive Russell Borthwick put the choice plainly: "The question is whether we produce more of it here, supporting British jobs, investment and energy security, or pay other countries to produce it for us."
Calling one North Sea field climate vandalism while approving its neighbours is a position that requires a coherent argument. Ministers have not provided one.
Published November 17, 2026 · Frisian News