
336 Police Contacts, 8 Deportation Attempts: Germany's 22-Year Removal Failure
November 21, 2026 · Frisian News
Photo: Wikimedia Commons
Dortmund police logged 336 contacts with a single man over 22 years while German authorities launched eight formal deportation proceedings, all of which failed. Officials now publicly doubt they will ever remove him.
336. That is the number of times Dortmund police have logged contact with a single man who has been legally required to leave Germany since March 2004. Eight formal deportation proceedings, targeting Morocco four times, Algeria twice, and Tunisia twice, all collapsed. More than two decades on, he remains.
The man, now 37, arrived in 2003 as an unaccompanied minor and claimed Moroccan nationality. His asylum claim was rejected and a removal order issued the following year. He has never produced a passport and has refused to sign applications for replacement travel documents. Under German law, the absence of a recognized travel document blocks forced removal.
Dortmund's mayor, Alexander Kalouti of the CDU, confirmed the full scale of the effort in a formal response to local Alternative for Germany politicians. Between 2006 and 2026, city officials made 18 formal requests for the man's cooperation on identity and passport matters. Embassy screenings and two separate identity-verification processes all produced no usable result. The state government of North Rhine-Westphalia placed the case in its "case conference" mechanism for especially difficult individual files in 2019, with involvement from the interior ministry, police, and immigration authorities.
Melanie Schmickler, head of Dortmund's migration office, has publicly stated she doubts deportation will ever succeed. She described the man as seriously mentally ill and suffering the long-term effects of drug addiction. He has been homeless, spent periods in secure psychiatric facilities, and repeatedly acted so chaotically during office appointments that security guards have had to remove him. Staff know him by sight.
The official line is that his refusal to cooperate on identity is the obstacle: without a recognized travel document, the law bars removal. That is accurate as a legal description. It does not explain why eight proceedings and 22 years produced no mechanism to override it.
The case is not exceptional. The Polish Centre for Eastern Studies, writing in September 2024, reported that of roughly 226,000 refugees in Germany, around 80 percent hold "tolerated stay" status, which effectively takes them off the active removal list. Germany deported 9,465 people in the first half of 2024, up 20 percent on the same period in 2023, with a full-year 2023 figure of 16,430. The country currently holds around 800 vacant places in detention centres for individuals required to leave. A March 2024 report from researchers at the Catholic University of Applied Sciences in Mainz discussed estimates of Germany's total irregular migrant population ranging up to 520,000.
Interior minister Alexander Dobrindt has pushed for sharper border enforcement since taking office. German police figures, reported by Die Welt, show 22,170 irregular entries recorded in Germany so far in 2025, against 83,572 in the same period in 2024 and 127,549 in 2023. Speaking in the Bundestag, Dobrindt said: "The integration capabilities of a country have their limits when it comes to illegal migration." A YouGov poll for the Süddeutsche Zeitung found 68 percent of CDU voters believe the new measures will work. Among AfD voters, 63 percent do not.
A government that cannot remove one man after 336 encounters and eight formal proceedings is not running a deportation system. It is running a filing system.
Published November 21, 2026 · Frisian News