Breaking
1.2 Billion Climate Refugees: What the IEP Study Actually Measured✦€805 Million Fine: Italy Hits Meta for Reading 20 Million Users' Photos Without Notice✦€600 Billion Spent, Germany Hits Worst Climate Ranking Since 2005✦70 Victims, 30 Years: Indian Student Who Overstayed His Visa Jailed for Grooming✦3,177 Objections, One Letter of Support: Rayner Forces Through Piddington Camp✦7 for 7: ECJ Dismisses All of Poland's Fit for 55 Climate Challenges✦1.2 Billion Climate Refugees: What the IEP Study Actually Measured✦€805 Million Fine: Italy Hits Meta for Reading 20 Million Users' Photos Without Notice✦€600 Billion Spent, Germany Hits Worst Climate Ranking Since 2005✦70 Victims, 30 Years: Indian Student Who Overstayed His Visa Jailed for Grooming✦3,177 Objections, One Letter of Support: Rayner Forces Through Piddington Camp✦7 for 7: ECJ Dismisses All of Poland's Fit for 55 Climate Challenges✦
Monday, 16 November 2026Est. 2026

FRISIAN NEWS

The numbers behind the news

€60,000 Charter, One Passenger: NRW Flies Boeing 737 to Deport One Man
Migration

€60,000 Charter, One Passenger: NRW Flies Boeing 737 to Deport One Man

November 9, 2026 · Frisian News

Photo: Wikimedia Commons

North Rhine-Westphalia chartered an entire Boeing 737 to deport a single Lebanese man to Bulgaria on 29 September, at an estimated cost of more than €60,000. The final bill has not arrived, and the state has 11,000 people under immediately enforceable removal orders.

English

A Boeing 737 carrying 189 seats took off from Düsseldorf on 29 September with one passenger on board. North Rhine-Westphalia chartered the Enter Air jet to deport a single Lebanese national to Sofia under EU Dublin rules. Estimated cost to NRW taxpayers: more than €60,000. The final bill has not yet arrived.

The man had entered the European Union through Bulgaria, then moved on to Germany. Dublin rules required his return to the first country of entry. Whether Bulgarian authorities will subsequently deport him to Lebanon is their decision alone.

He flew alone because other planned deportations failed. NRW's refugee ministry told Bild: "The seat allocation is not fully filled when individual return measures fail." The ministry cited three typical causes: deportees not found at their registered address, health conditions making travel impossible, or voluntary departure before the flight date. According to RTL.de, charter contracts can only be cancelled up to 72 hours before departure. When a deportation collapses on the day itself, the empty seats still cost the same.

The €60,000-plus figure is an estimate. For a similar operation carrying seven people, Bild reported charter costs of around €63,000 alone, with ancillary charges of €1,510.86 for medical staff, €328.03 for interpreters, €114.78 for food, and €721.46 for airport fees. Seven completed 2025 charter flights for which final accounts were submitted to the state parliament under Drucksache 18/21860 cost a combined €515,936.38, according to Kölner Stadt-Anzeiger. That is an average of around €73,705 per flight, with individual flights ranging from €49,748 to €98,219.

In all of 2025, NRW chartered eleven planes for EU deportations, with two to twenty people on each, according to nius.de. No prior flight had carried just one person. Across 2025 and 2026 combined, Kölner Stadt-Anzeiger reported that NRW booked 17 charter planes and removed 143 people in total.

The September operation was not the first to draw attention. Around eighteen months earlier, according to Kölner Stadt-Anzeiger, NRW chartered a full Airbus to fly four Syrian and three Afghan men to Bulgaria. That flight drew public scrutiny. The ones that followed went unremarked until Kölner Stadt-Anzeiger asked the ministry for a full accounting.

The ministry offered an explanation. Destination countries control the intake caps, often restricting arrivals to ten people per operation, and those negotiations sit with the federal government in Berlin, not Düsseldorf. It told Kölner Stadt-Anzeiger that the "logistical, procedural and organisational effort" across the multiple agencies involved means group charters are "regularly more effective than individual measures." That framing says nothing about the cost per person when the group shrinks to one.

According to focus.de and nius.de, around 56,000 people in NRW are currently subject to a departure obligation. Approximately 11,000 of them hold no Duldung, meaning their obligation to leave is immediately enforceable. At the 2025 average of €73,705 per charter flight, the numbers speak for themselves.

One passenger, a plane full of empty seats, and a final invoice the state cannot yet produce.


Published November 9, 2026 · Frisian News