
Acquitted in Minutes: Scottish Father Prosecuted for Words Muttered in a Closed Car
November 22, 2026 · Frisian News
Photo: Wikimedia Commons
A Glasgow father was charged with a hate crime for muttering a racial slur inside his closed car after a near-motorway collision, with no one outside the vehicle able to hear him. The Free Speech Union secured a not-guilty verdict within minutes at trial in November 2026.
Four out of five burglaries in Glasgow go unsolved. There were 11 car thefts per 10,000 people in the year to June 2026, Free Speech Union general secretary Toby Young wrote in The Spectator. Police Scotland found time, however, to charge a father of a four-year-old with a hate crime for words he muttered inside a closed car that nobody outside could hear. He was acquitted within minutes.
The case began in April 2025. Craig, a Glasgow man identified only by pseudonym, was driving his son home on the M80 after a day at an amusement park in Falkirk when another vehicle cut across his path and forced him to swerve. Suspecting the other driver was drunk, Craig called the police from his car. Both vehicles stopped. Officers attended and, according to Brussels Signal and the Scottish Daily Express, declined to breathalyse either driver. They took Craig's dashcam footage instead.
A week later, officers returned the footage and told Craig an offence had been committed. By him, not the other driver. The dashcam audio had captured him muttering "smelly black b*stard" under his breath seconds after the near-miss. Police Scotland charged him with "threatening or abusive behaviour" under Section 38 of the Criminal Justice and Licensing (Scotland) Act 2010, with a racial aggravation. That offence carries up to 12 months in prison on summary conviction.
The Free Speech Union, which assisted Craig's legal defence, noted that the car's windows were closed. The other driver was not looking in Craig's direction. The only other person present was his four-year-old son. When Craig asked the officer reading him his rights how he could be charged for speaking to himself inside his own vehicle, she replied, according to Brussels Signal: "The language was still racist."
At a hearing in early November before a justice of the peace, Craig was acquitted within minutes. The Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service (COPFS) defended the prosecution in a statement to the Scottish Daily Express: "It is inaccurate to characterise this case solely as relating to words muttered under a person's breath. The evidence before the court related to the accused's wider conduct and circumstances of the incident." The court did not share that view.
Young, a Conservative peer, condemned both Police Scotland and COPFS for pursuing the charge. His figures on burglaries and car theft show where investigative resources are not going. The only evidence against Craig, Young noted in The Spectator, was the dashcam footage Craig had voluntarily handed to police in the hope of seeing the dangerous driver prosecuted.
Scotland's Hate Crime and Public Order Act 2021 came into force on April 1, 2024, covering six protected characteristics including race as aggravating factors in criminal charges. Brussels Signal reported that Police Scotland received 7,152 online hate reports in the first week after the law took effect, of which 240 were recorded as hate crimes. Craig's prosecution came the following year.
The legal test under Section 38, as Young explained in The Spectator, requires the Crown to show the behaviour would likely cause a reasonable person fear or alarm, and that the accused intended that outcome or was reckless as to it. Craig said the words to himself, windows shut. He was found not guilty.
The other driver Craig reported was not charged.
Published November 22, 2026 · Frisian News