The Welfare State Is Not Sustainable. We Should Say So.
January 13, 2026 · Frisian News
Western governments spend more on pensions and benefits than they collect in taxes. Politicians avoid naming the problem, but the math does not change.
In the Netherlands, pension funds face a shortfall of 400 billion euros over the next three decades. Germany's state pension system requires constant subsidies from the general budget, now running at 100 billion euros yearly. France spends over 14 percent of its GDP on pensions alone, up from 10 percent in 1990. These are not projections or warnings. These are current facts, and they worsen every year.
Politicians across Europe treat this as a technical problem to be managed by committees and actuaries. They propose small tax increases, minor age adjustments, or vague promises about future growth. None of it adds up. You cannot pay out 14 percent of GDP in pensions when you collect 10 percent of GDP in pension contributions. The gap does not close through better administration or more optimistic forecasts. It closes through cuts, tax hikes, or currency debasement. Those are the only three options.
The welfare state as built after 1945 rested on assumptions that no longer hold. Young populations, high birth rates, stable employment, and long-term economic growth powered the original systems. Europe now has aging populations, below-replacement fertility, precarious work patterns, and sluggish growth. We tried to transplant a 1950s machine into a 2020s landscape. It cannot work. Pretending otherwise wastes another decade while the problem hardens.
Speaking plainly about this does not require cruelty or indifference. A functioning welfare system can exist at lower levels of spending. Countries can redirect resources to care for the truly needy while reducing payments to those who do not need them. They can raise retirement ages to match actual life expectancy. They can shift from state pensions to funded individual accounts. None of these moves is impossible or immoral. What is immoral is silence.
The longer governments avoid honest conversation, the harsher the correction will be. Sudden cuts hit retirees with no time to adjust. Debasement strikes savers and fixed-income earners hardest. Slow-motion insolvency undermines trust in institutions. A small country with sense would begin talks now, propose real changes, and spread the adjustment across years. Most will wait until markets force their hand, and then suffer crisis instead.
Yn Nederlân hawwe pensioenfûnsen in tekoart fan 400 miljard euro yn 'e kommende trije desennia. Dûtsk steatspensioen kostet jierlik 100 miljard euro oan subsidys út 'e algemiene begroting. Frankryk jouwt mear as 14 persint fan syn BBP út oan pensioenen, tsjin 10 persint yn 1990. Dit binne gjin prognôzes of warskôgingen. Dit binne aktuele feiten, en sy waorsje elk jier.
Politisi yn gans Europa behannele dit as in tinysk probleem dat komitees en aktuarisssen beheare kinne. Se stelle lytse belestinferheagingen foar, lytse leeftydsoanpassingen of vage beloften oer takomstige groei. Gjin ien dâr gaat op. Do kinne net 14 persint fan it BBP útkearde as pensioen as do allinne 10 persint fan it BBP ynsamskje. It gat slút net troch better behear of optimistyskere foarsizzingen. It slút troch besunigings, belestinferheagingen of geldomte. Dit binne de allinne trije opsjes.
De soargsteat lykas opricht nei 1945 basearre op oannames dy't net mear hâlde. Jonge befolking, heige bearthgetallen, stabile wurk en langdurige ekonomyske groei dreaun de orizjinele stelsels. Europa hat no in ferâlderande befolking, ûnderferplanting, ûnsieker wurk en trage groei. Wy probearren in masine út de jierren 1950 yn in lânskap fan de jierren 2020 yn. Dit kin net. Do allinne dwaan as dat it wel kin, fergildt in oar desennje wylst it probleem hurder wurdt.
Earlik sprekke dêr oer fereasket gjin wreedheid of ûnferskilligheid. In funktsjonearre stelsels kin besteane mei legere útjowingen. Lannen kinne middels rjochte op echte noden wylst se betellingen oan wa't it net nocht hat fermindere. Se kinne pensjoenleftiden ferheage nei werklike libbenswachting. Se kinne fan steatpensioen nei finansjearre privé-rekkeningen wikselje. Gjin fan dizze stappen is ûnmooglik of ûnmoraal. Wat ûnmoraal is, is swijen.
Hoe langer regearingen earlik prate foarkomme, hoe hurder de koreksje wol wêze. Fluch besunigings treffe pensjonearren sûnder tiid om oan te passen. Geldomte slacht spare en faste-ynkomsten-gebrûkers grutst. Trage insolvabiliteit ûndermûne fertrouwen yn ynstitusjons. In lytse lân mei fertán soe no prate starte, echte feroaringen foar stelle en de oanpassing oer jierren ferspriede. De mearste sille wachtsje oant merkten se dwinge, en dan krisis ûndergean yn stee dêrfan.
Published January 13, 2026 · Frisian News · Ljouwert, Fryslân